by Max Barry

Latest Forum Topics

Advertisement

7

DispatchBulletinCampaign

by 10ki wa secretariat. . 36 reads.

GA "Long-Term Storage Of Produced Waste" Voting Overview

Overview

Proposal:
This proposal aims to safely store waste through businesses utilizing correct storage facilities and reducing overall waste.

Opinions:

For:
The Secretariat was unable to compile any arguments for this proposal.

Against:

Bananaistan wrote:“There are major issues here not least the fact that the proposing delegation did not do the rest of us the courtesy of providing us with the text of the proposal themselves, and did not open a debate themselves prior to asking us to vote on it.

“The requirement that every single business with an “industrial facility” must have a huge 70 year private dump regardless of the scope of the business is insane.

“The fact that this is stated as a requirement but then the following clause makes it optional is insane. Just what exactly are these businesses supposed to do?

“Then who pays for the 70 years of professional maintenance?

“Investing time and resources in assisting the effort to an non-contained waste-free world” is meaningless drivel.

“This general requirement to “reduce waste discharge” is bonkers. Specific problems have been addressed in other resolutions. It’s hardly the concern of this assemble if an old newspaper happens to blow out the door of a factory.

“This penalties thing. In the incredibly unlikely event that this proposal isn’t rightly utterly rejected by the assembly, I can assure you that the penalty in Bananaistan will be no more than 1/4d per millennium.

“Overall this will be a waste of the assembly’s time. It’s a shame that normal custom and practice has not been followed by the proposing delegation. Someone would have advised them not to bother and not waste everyone’s time.”

Calamari lands wrote:"The Calamarilandese Delegacy voted against because of the lack of a drafting process. This makes the proposal's quality very dubious."

10ki wa secretariat

RawReport