13
Dispatch → Bulletin → Campaign
by 
The Regional Nation of The Northern Light.
.
65 reads.
Vote For GA resolution Repeal: "Protecting Personal Data"
Resolution Analysis
The target proposal possesses large flaws that harm its effectiveness and lead to unintended effects. This includes firms' incentive to not collect data so as to avoid the mandates, as well as not considering the possible legitimate reasons for minors having personal data stored without explicit consent. Furthermore, as outlined by the repeal, the target hampers the ability for civil courts to uncover all the evidence relevant to their respective cases and private entities from receiving court mandated action or compensation.
In accordance with this and our pervious IFV on this topic, the Ministry of World Assembly recommends a vote For this repeal.
Previous IFV:
Resolution Analysis
The proposal, despite its well-meaning intentions, appears to create unnecessary requirements for member governments to collect and analyze data, especially for noncriminal cases in which warrants would never come into play. When it comes to criminal cases, the proposal seems to mandate warrants to severely limit the scope of what can actually be done regarding investigations made by member governments. Furthermore, the mandates made by the proposal seem to be overly ambiguous, allowing for member governments to evade requirements by citing loosely defined terms such as 'well being of users' or 'safety or disciplinary reason.' In summary, the proposal takes an approach that is too simple to capture some of the more complicated facets of data collection.
In accordance with the reasons displayed above, the Ministry of World Assembly Affairs recommends a vote Against the proposal.
